Cory Booker on Banning Automatic Transmissions in Cars

Introduction

Cory Booker, the Democratic senator from New Jersey, has proposed a bill that would ban the sale of new cars with automatic transmissions in the United States by 2035. The bill, called the Zero Emissions Vehicle Act, would also require all new cars sold in the country to be electric vehicles by 2040.

Booker’s proposal has been met with mixed reactions. Some have praised it as a bold move that will help to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and improve air quality. Others have criticized it as being unrealistic and impractical.

Arguments in Favor of Banning Automatic Transmissions

There are several arguments in favor of banning automatic transmissions in cars.

1. Reduced greenhouse gas emissions: Automatic transmissions are less efficient than manual transmissions, which means that they produce more greenhouse gases. A study by the Union of Concerned Scientists found that cars with automatic transmissions emit about 10% more greenhouse gases than cars with manual transmissions.
2. Improved air quality: Greenhouse gases are not the only pollutants produced by cars. Automatic transmissions also produce more particulate matter, which can contribute to respiratory problems. A study by the American Lung Association found that cars with automatic transmissions emit about 20% more particulate matter than cars with manual transmissions.
3. Improved fuel economy: Manual transmissions are more efficient than automatic transmissions, which means that they can help drivers to save money on fuel. A study by the Environmental Protection Agency found that cars with manual transmissions get about 5% better fuel economy than cars with automatic transmissions.
4. Increased driver engagement: Manual transmissions require drivers to be more engaged in the driving process, which can lead to a more enjoyable driving experience. Some drivers also believe that manual transmissions give them more control over their cars.

Arguments Against Banning Automatic Transmissions

There are also several arguments against banning automatic transmissions in cars.

1. Increased cost: Manual transmissions are more expensive to produce than automatic transmissions, which would likely lead to higher prices for new cars.
2. Reduced accessibility: Manual transmissions can be difficult to operate for some drivers, such as those with disabilities or who are new to driving. A ban on automatic transmissions would make it more difficult for these drivers to operate vehicles.
3. Reduced safety: Some drivers believe that automatic transmissions are safer than manual transmissions, as they can help to prevent accidents caused by driver error. A ban on automatic transmissions could lead to an increase in accidents.
4. Impact on the economy: The automotive industry is a major part of the U.S. economy. A ban on automatic transmissions could lead to job losses and economic hardship in this sector.

Conclusion

The debate over whether or not to ban automatic transmissions in cars is a complex one. There are valid arguments on both sides of the issue. Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to ban automatic transmissions is a political one that will be made by elected officials.

In the meantime, consumers can make their own choices about whether to buy cars with automatic or manual transmissions. If you are concerned about the environment, fuel economy, or driver engagement, you may want to consider buying a car with a manual transmission. However, if you are looking for a car that is easy to operate, affordable, and safe, you may want to consider buying a car with an automatic transmission.